Double Marginalization Problem
This short video covers the double marginalization problem. The problem is what happens to social welfare, prices, and profits when one monopoly sells to another
This short video covers the double marginalization problem. The problem is what happens to social welfare, prices, and profits when one monopoly sells to another monopoly. It is a classic problem with applications in industrial organization, innovation policy, and development.
Contributed Content (0) and Suggested Materials (5)
Ask a Question
The answer to practice question #6 that seems correct to me is considered as incorrect by the system -- I wonder who is right...
Corrected. Please bear in mind that MRU Development Economics is basically just Tyler and myself. We do have some great student and technical help but sometimes errors sneak through, especially on our first run. Our motto of Learn, Teach, Share reminds everyone that this is a joint enterprise like Wikipedia so we are grateful when people spot errors.
I don't think I heard an explanation as to why the slope of the marginal revenue curve was twice that of the demand curve. Is this something I should already know?
It's not terribly important but it is easy to prove with a bit of calculus. Write an inverse linear demand curve as P=A-bQ. Note that A is the vertical intercept and b is the slope. Revenue is P*Q or PQ=AQ-bQ^2 now take the derivative to get MR=A-2bQ, i.e. a curve which begins at the same vertical intercept, A and has a slope of 2b.
I got this question wrong twice, which means I got the monkey score. But unlike any monkey, I watched the video twice. So there is clearly something I don't understand. Please help.
The question is:
5. In a standard monopoly model, a monopoly produces less than the competitive market. The difference between the monopoly output and the competitive output (the trades which do not take place as a result of monopoly distortion) is known as: *
a) dead weight loss
b) monopoly profit cost
c) monopolistic loss
The correct answer (by elimination) is a. Now this doesn't make any sense to me. I understood dwl to be the money left on the table by any retailer who doesn't lower prices. If I sell widgets at $10 per, and 100 people buy widgets at a profit of $2 per, then I make $200. On the other hand, were I to sell 500 widgets at $8 per, I'd sell a lot more widgets, but my profit would be zero. The difference in revenue (not profit) is the dwl. Is this correct?
Monopoly profit means I can sell 50 widgets at $20 and make a lot more money. But the DWL is now 450 widgets at $8 each, and you do the math--it's a big number.
Well, if so, then how can the answer to the above question be dwl?
Good question. Here is what you are missing. Dead weight loss is NOT about profits. DWL is a measure of social loss, to be precise DWL measures potential gains from trade that do not occur. The height of the demand curve at the Xth unit tells us the value that consumers place on the Xth unit of the good, the height of the MC curve at the Xth unit tells us the cost of producing that unit. Thus, whenever the demand curve is above the MC curve there is a potential gain from trade. The trouble is that a monopoly can increase profit by reducing output (for the reasons you explain in your question) even though less output means fewer gains from trade and more DWL. In other words, producing more would lower the monopolist's profit but it would increase social surplus--that is it would increase consumer surplus more than the loss in monopoly profits so society as whole would be better off.
For this to make any sense you have to assume that no bargaining is possible between the two firms. The net result is more likely to depend on each firm's outside opportunities. It also required fixed unit pricing amongst a long list of assumptions that don't seem appropriate.
Clearly the downstream producer is making far less profit when the upstream producer pushes prices upwards. All the downstream producer has to say is "fine, bugger off. I won't buy any of you stuff anymore." That threatens both of their profits and enables them to coordinate prices and quantities to maximise their combined surpluses. This maximised surplus is then shared proportionally to the outside opportunities of each firm.
I mean, aren't there a whole bunch of game theory models that show monopoly selling power is restrained by a monopoly buyer? I can think of a few off the top of my head if there is not.
I'm having a very hard time imagining any real life situation where this can apply, and not be circumvented.
Indeed, I can hardly think of a situation where some degree of monopoly power is not inherent in all stages of production. So this problem should be rife - energy, shipping, resources, property markets, etc. I'm surprised we can produce anything.
Dead-weight loss is considered to be a net social loss. The video mentions a couple of times: "the economy shrinks". But I think we miss part of the story. The thing is that when a monopoly ends up producing less than what would be produced in perfect competition, it frees up resources that can be used up in other industries, thus affecting demand and supply in those other industries in favor of more production. I think we have here some "live-weight gains" that can, at least partially, offset dead-weight losses in industries affected by lack of competition. So, can we apply this Bastiatesque reasoning here?
I'm confused by the Microsoft example. There was no web browser market at all, let alone a monopoly in one. So this doesn't address the charges of the antitrust suit, namely that MS was stifling innovation by bundling its browser with its OS.
Also: have you not noticed that even now Internet Explorer sucks? The only reason it's marginally improved since the 90s is because of the competition from other browsers. One in particular....
I agree that the bundling issue is separate from this video, but I think what Alex was really getting at is that originally Netscape Navigator was not free. When Microsoft came out with IE it was priced at zero in a sense. In response to this Navigator eventually had to also lower its price to zero as well and try to make money through indirect means like advertising/portal. Microsoft probably made a mistake as they would have dominated browsers anyways without the bundling issues.
Chrome is better than IE now, but it is also free. Most browser software is now a part of companies that produce operating system software as well. There are a few exceptions, but most importantly Microsoft lowered the price of browser software to zero.
I'm so happy I got to start working at JBC last year. After working for about 8 years now, they finally brought me some fashion back in my life..free credit score
I have been reading in a class and we are looking at this subject in the next week. I will be assign my student to look at your post for good information. ...flying to Canada with DWI
has been well served by Reward Van Hire for the last 15 years. Trading out of Kentish Town, North London, Reward Van Hire provides top quality self-drive van hire, truck hire and minibus hire to individuals and trade customers alike. van hire london
Keep blogging the good stuff. this is one of the best articles on this website. definitely excellent information and hope to read more.yacon diet hypnosis
If your computer or network is protected by a firewall or proxy, make sure that Firefox is permitted to access the Web male enhancement products
I love this song. When ever I listen to it, it brings me construction equipment salvage
back to when my husband and I first started dating...and it's all true. We are going on five years of marriage and he still makes me feel like I wanna dance and play!
Appreciation for being really thoughtful and also for deciding on writing certain guides most people are really wanting to be aware of. Taxi Tlemcen
Black friars Bridge on Friday night as a protest against Transport for Home Page
London's plans to proceed with the flawed design for the northern junction.
Awesome notify i mold utter further blesss for the info. Science is definitely a gummy liable. Nevertheless, is immobile amid the foremost texts of our day. I understand your announce further peep relay to extra. www.azucohost.com/
I found this amazingly remarkable, accompanying tremendous share of excel occasions plus any astounding components.Blesss a multiple for revealing your maze usher. http://www.azucohost.com
Art & More fertigt Ihren Bilderrahmen oder Ihr Passepartout auch in Sondergrößen. Sonderformate bei Wechselrahmen, rahmenlosen Bildhaltern oder Passepartouts sind jederzeit möglich,as explained here
wir liefern Ihnen jedes gewünschte Format.--
I'm going to read this. I'll be sure to come back. thanks for sharing. and also This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. this is very nice one and gives indepth information. thanks for this nice article weekend
good to be here in your article or post, whatever, I think I should also work hard for my own website like I see some good and updated working in your site. my email list
SindhudurgPalaceResort.com - Welcome to Sindhudurg's best resort located in Kudal with luxurious & top quality services. With scenic beauty, multicuisine restaurant and luxurious room services you're sure to have a memorable time.
beach resorts in sindhudurg
Three are usually cheap Ralph Lauren available for sale each and every time you wish to buy. They're produced by the very best degree developers who will be distinguished for your polo dress as an example creating. You'll find polo Ron Lauren inside exclusive array which include particular classes for men, women.
Đồng hồ đeo tay nam sẽ cung cấp cho các khách hàng nam những chiếc đồng hồ lịch lãm, thể hiện sức mạnh cũng như cá tính của người đeo. Đồng hồ đeo tay nữ thời trang sẽ làm cho đôi tay của các bạn nữ một dấu ấn khó phai. Trẻ em hay các khách hàng trong độ tuổi đi học sẽ tìm được những mẫu đồng hồ dành đúng cho lứa tuổi của mình. Tất cả đều có tại Đồng hồ Rexy. dong ho deo tay
They combine, you’ll be fascinated to know, the kind of technologyRead More Here you’d expect to find in the aerospace with the sort of stuff you find on a bicycle. - Lifecell Under Eye
exercisers are in general choosing an innovative outside physical workout software ınstead of toiling to getting a gymnasium. -Ben 10
Der Schwerpunkt unseres Angebots liegt in der Konzeption, Gestaltung und Entwicklung von Websites sowie im Online Marketing. SEO-Optimierung, Social Media Marketing (SMM) oder Responsive Webdesign sind dabei keine Fremdwörter für uns, sondern Teil unserer täglichen Arbeit.SEO
You are so skilled! Much obliged! What an awesome written work, truly I acknowledge such sort of themes. Call Recorder
Fotograf Reinhard Simon und Waltraud Pioch begrüßen Sie herzlich in ihrem Fotostudio “das portrait” in Frankfurt. Fotoatelier für anspruchsvolle Fotografie. Die erste Adresse in Frankfurt für Bewerbungsfotos, Businessfotos und Portraitfotos. Frankfurt
I’m happy I located this blog! From time to time, students want to cognitive the keys of productive literary essays composing. Your first-class knowledge about this good post can become a proper basis for such people. Safe Work Method Statement Template SA
Thank you very much! My friends and family members will be happy after hearing about this as. taxi from delhi to jaipur
A noteworthy offer, I recently given this onto an associate who was doing a little examination on this. Also, he actually purchased me breakfast in light of the fact that I discovered it for him.. grin. So give me a chance to rephrase that: Thnx for the treat! In any case no doubt Thnkx for investing the time to examine this, I feel firmly about it and adoration perusing all the more on this theme. In the event that conceivable, as you get to be aptitude, would you see any problems with redesigning your web journal with more points of interest? It is profoundly useful for me. Enormous thumb up for this blog entry!
Property Management Prahran
If your computer or network is protected by a firewall or proxy, make sure that Firefox is permitted to access the Web. Loft conversions Chiswick
Bei uns finden Sie sämtliches Zubehör zum Aufhängen von Bildern. Vom einfachsten Bilderhaken bis hin zur Bildaufhängung mit Diebstahlschutz. Wir als Bilderrahmenprofi haben hier alle Produkte zur Bildaufhängung in einem Shop zusammengestellt. Zackenaufhänger