Property Rights 3: Communal Property, Enclosure and the State
Were classic (fee-simple) property rights an unintended side-effect of government's desire to tax? We look at communal property, private property, taxation and some
Were classic (fee-simple) property rights an unintended side-effect of government's desire to tax? We look at communal property, private property, taxation and some of James C. Scott's ideas in his book Seeing Like a State.
Contributed Content (0) and Suggested Materials (6)
Ask a Question
I guess that individual property is tied with individual freedom, because the will to possess -that is to make whatever you wish with some thing- seems atavistic and it is an important part of our idea of individual freedom. This atavistic will also involves some violence in the first appropriations, but if we try to abolish the individual property a sustained violence is needed to repress the natural tendency to possess and to act freely that all we carry inside.
Thanks for adressing this interesting topic and identifying property rights as what they are: A controversial, theoretical construct in economics.
Wallace, North & Weingast's "Violence and Social Orders" has some material on the development of fee simple property rights in medieval europe. They explained the meaning of the latin terms involved, but now I can't remember then. Elinor Ostrom's "Governing the Commons" has material on how communities have managed resources and avoided (or failed to avoid) the tragedy of the commons. Additionally I'd note that Timur Kuran's "The Great Divergence", while not about communal property, does discuss how the failure of the islamic legal system to evolve led them to fall behind europe. Having multiple claimants to property as a result of inheritance laws & partnerships (rather than having an immortal corporation own everything) made it hard to keep a business going, unless you endowed a waqf which had an inflexible public/communal purpose to serve.
James Scott proposes that fee simple property is an invention of the state to make control of people and taxation of people more feasible and efficient. Does the historical record support this hypothesis? I'm not a historian, but I doubt that historical records support Scott's proposition. It seems entirely likely that individuals owning property privately precedes the existence of any state. Every individual takes himself to own himself and whatever he produces, just as Locke proposed. Private ownership of plots of land seems much more likely to be a natural extension of self ownership and use of land, rather than an intentional construct of a set of people calling themselves "the state."
Would a modern society even be possible without enclosure? I mean that the surplus labour resulting from agricultural property merging had to go somewhere. They probably went to jobs with a comparative advantage (factories?). So in the long run could you not argue that all parts of the former community benefitted although only after some time.
Your website is choked with authentic and highly-researched knowledge that's price reading. opticians london
This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles cheap contact lenses
JSN PowerAdmin and which new features we have added. Here I will describe the main changes in this release. Minimalist Home Furniture
I like visiting you site since Is always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that.Do Keep sharing! Regards. online payday loans
here are the easiest method to appreciate your energy, which is why why I am going to the website everyday..here are the easiest method to appreciate your energy, which is why why I am going to the website everyday..
n Chile conditional cash transfers has started to implement just a couple of years ago. The program is called "ingreso etico familiar" (faliliar ethic income) who cosnsist in cash transfers to a family conditioned th vision improvement without surgery
nice post, keep up with this interesting work. It really is good to know that this topic is being covered also on this web site so cheers for taking time to discuss this! www.enriqueiglesias.com
been reading along. I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end -jaipur local sightseeing by car
Hi there! My name is Jackseo40 I have 1 year experience in the internet marketing field. I have worked as SEO (Search Engine Optimisaton), Link Building and SMS (Social Media Serivces) consultant for several websites. I love helping businesses succeed in this constantly evolving online world....buy dofollow blog comments
you will be assured of the comprehensive and thorough way we approach all projects from the outset....free credit reports from all 3 bureaus
Welcome to the best place for free marvels contest of champions hack cheat, our hack is completely secure and can be used to generate unlimited resources, and our hack works online o you do not need to download any software that might be a virus also the hack tool is so fast and simple to use and can generate free resources within a minute.marvel contest of champions game cheats
Garcinia Cambogia Max also boosts the body's metabolism, allowing it to function as a fat burning furnace.http://garciniacambogia-freetrial.net
Great post ,i was looking for stuff like that on internet and found your website.You guys are doing good job.Keep it up . Injustice Cheats
If You Are Looking To Increase The Search Engine Page Rank Permanently And Online Visibility Of Your Website, Please Try Our HIGH Quality Actual Page Rank Pr2 To Pr7 Manual Blog Commenting Service. Google Love Unique Content, And If Your Backlinks Are Coming From High PR Pages With A Unique Content, You Will See Increase In The SERP And Online Visibility Of Your Website.give you 72 dofollow blog commets Pr7 to Pr2 exclusive offers
What can drive success for contractors in the marketplace and how does that ties in with Milwaukee’s distribution partners at that point in time..turbo force
It is very true, people must learn how to learn before they can learn. loll i know it sounds funny but its very true. . - blogging sites for beginners
The primary a few months of my site there were no remarks; simply provide for it time; now they come in like insane consistently! Much obliged.http://www.antoniapearceromance.com/
I would think that agricultural productivity is more often like Stephen Jay Gould's theory of punctuated equilibrium. In other words.. idaho falls air duct cleaning
I am just pretty happy to sign up ones own guestbook these days,Your own feedback and listed below are excellent in my opinion,incidentally I should say also definitely will teach some great supplements for your needs every.gift for new parents